| 1 | # Open questions for Clover |
| 2 | |
| 3 | 1. **One editor at a time in conservative mode.** §2 lets read-only agents run |
| 4 | alongside, but editing agents take turns in the shared checkout. |
| 5 | **Lean:** keep; Snowbound's shared working copy broke builds and swept |
| 6 | half-edits into commits. The alternative is parallel editors on disjoint |
| 7 | claims. |
| 8 | 2. **What unlocks autonomous mode.** §2 counts "you're the maintainer", "use |
| 9 | worktrees" and "work through the tracker". "keep shipping" triggers the skill |
| 10 | but unlocks nothing. **Lean:** keep that split, so a work repo never goes |
| 11 | autonomous on a casual phrase. |
| 12 | 3. **State location.** `NOW.md` and `DECISIONS.md` sit where project memory |
| 13 | says, else `~/.local/state/orchestrate/<project>/`. The log is its own file |
| 14 | because `NOW.md` is rewritten and a rewrite could drop decisions. |
| 15 | **Lean:** keep both. |
| 16 | 4. **jj rewrites beyond AGENTS.md's default set.** §3 lets the named rewriter |
| 17 | squash, rebase, restore, abandon and restore operations. **Lean:** the skill |
| 18 | grants it for orchestrated repos; AGENTS.md's default holds everywhere else. |
| 19 | 5. **Default stop rule.** §7 proposes "no P1 or P2 inside the threat model; P3 |
| 20 | and copy batch into the next release". Your words only said to agree one up |
| 21 | front. **Lean:** keep it as the starting offer. |
| 22 | 6. **"On a fork, matching upstream is usually the simpler thing."** It decided |
| 23 | the Claude usage endpoint, but HANDOFF doesn't say whether that rule was |
| 24 | yours. **Lean:** keep the clause if it's yours, otherwise cut it. |
| 25 | 7. **Brief overlap with `ui-review-loop`.** Its `references/agent-brief.md` |
| 26 | shares most headings with `references/brief.md`. **Lean:** this brief is the |
| 27 | base; ui-review-loop's keeps the UI parts (verify block, taste calls, |
| 28 | screenshots) and points here. |
| 29 | 8. **Knife facts cut from the skill:** the manifest shell-hash check (code |
| 30 | release or shell release) and the hot-update turn gap. **Lean:** they go in |
| 31 | the Knife's AGENTS.md; the turn-gap line is deleted when its fix ships. |
| 32 | 9. **`skills/README.md`** says `orchestrate` works best with "an issue tracker |
| 33 | the agent can write to". **Lean:** add "in autonomous mode". |
| 34 | 10. **First enforcement to build** from `references/safety-checklist.md`. |
| 35 | **Lean:** the scratch launcher and `JJ_EDITOR=false`; those cover the leaks |
| 36 | into your real home and the hung squash. |